Breaking
Advertisement
Transportation

Financing: the Luxembourg Rail Protocol can underwrite a rail resurgence

Quick Read

Now being adopted by a growing number of states, the Luxembourg Rail Protocol offers strong protections for private investors in rolling stock, leading to lower financing costs and other benefits, as Howard Rosen, Chairman of the Rail Working Group, explains. Worldwide, it used to be said that rail was a sunset industry. No longer; the railway world is turning. Unless you are directly affected, you may not have noticed this yet, because institutional change in the rail sector happens so slowly. But with some notable outliers, open access in both freight and passenger rail is either already in place or is coming. Governments and state-owned agencies are gradually withdrawing from the operation of both passenger and freight train services, or at least sharing, delegating, or concessioning operations to private operators. An idea whose time has come Early next year, 11 operators will be offering freight transport services on the South African rail network. Mozambique announced in June 2026 that it would follow the same strategy. ‘Our approach to logistics is clear: you cannot run logistics with a monopoly’, declared Minister of Transport & Logistics João Matlombe earlier this year. Other parts of Africa and the Americas are following, or looking to follow, the same path. In Europe there is already a type of open access in rail freight, and this is developing in passenger rail with more open access in countries including France, Italy, Spain, Sweden, and the Czech Republic. This will have profound implications for the rail sector: in the future, if not already now, the primary focus of state budgets will be on railway infrastructure, leaving train operations to private companies or to publicly owned operators financed by the private sector. However, this shift must also be accompanied by suitable changes to the way the rail sector is governed. To that end, the Luxembourg Rail Protocol to the Cape Town Convention is an international treaty that has now been in force for just over two years. The Rail Working Group is the not-for-profit association which supports the implementation of the treaty. It has already been ratified by seven states (plus the EU in respect of its competences) and will play a critical role in this evolution in two key regards. One is obvious; the other may surprise you. The protocol applies when a debtor asset lessee is based in a ratifying state. It is already making it easier and cheaper to finance rolling stock where there are no government guarantees. The treaty does this by creating a global legal framework that secures creditors, giving them clear rights on debtor default or insolvency, and providing a public international registry in Luxembourg, at which security interests may be registered. It applies to all types of rolling stock, from locomotives to wagons to metro trains and trams, new and used. In praise of URVIS The Luxembourg Protocol also introduces, for the first time, a global unique vehicle identification system (URVIS), whereby the international registry issues a 16-digit number on request. This is akin to the VIN number stamped on the chassis of every car, introduced more than 40 years ago. This number must be permanently attached to the vehicle in accordance with the UN Model Rules setting out minimum standards for the marking of railway rolling stock. At €15, the cost of an URVIS number is minimal. Tracking technology using the URVIS number allows creditors, keepers, insurers — and indeed operators — to track the location and use of the vehicles in real time. This is a game changer. The key to being able to offer asset-based financing is the ability to unequivocally identify the collateral. If this is not possible, banks and other creditors will lend or lease based on the creditworthiness of the debtor/lessee, thereby locking out (or at least pricing out) smaller, entrepreneurial, but less well capitalised, operators. Private operators need rolling stock. They can lease or buy it, often with bank credit. Effectively, this is the other side of the open access coin. The more private operators, the more the need for private capital. So the Luxembourg Protocol will be a key tool for private sector operators. Moreover, even state operators will be looking to utilise more private capital where government guarantees may be restricted for operations outside of the home jurisdiction, and are also increasingly being challenged by non-state actors pointing out the absence of a level playing field. Why standards are essential In many parts of the world, technical challenges remain, even beyond the existence of different gauges. Customisation of rolling stock and the lack of common standards continues to hinder the industry. The growing market for private finance of rolling stock will expose this as financially unsustainable. Standardised rail equipment operating across borders with harmonised technical standards will increase the residual values of rolling stock, thereby reducing lease rates and opening the way to secondary markets for rolling stock, cheaper maintenance, economies of scale for manufacturers, and lower prices for customers. But this only works if there are common legal standards that provide security to creditors, enabling them to reduce risk and offer finance at competitive rates. That is why the Luxembourg Rail Protocol will play an increasingly important role in supporting operators seeking attractive finance rates; manufacturers looking to develop, against tough competition, domestic and export markets; and banks, export credit agencies and insurers striving to reduce risk and therefore their pricing. In its recent report, Connecting Europe through High Speed Rail, the European Commission clearly acknowledged that private finance will be essential for the successful development of high speed rail in Europe, and it specifically invited member states to ratify the Luxembourg Protocol as a mechanism to help stimulate investment in rolling stock. “ ‘Currently, most states have no common identification system for all types of rolling stock nationally, let alone internationally’ ” The hidden benefit But there is another role that the Luxembourg Protocol will play, and this is less obvious. The availability, for the first time, of a global unique vehicle identification system for rolling stock is also highly relevant for regulators. Where there are multiple operators running rolling stock on railway infrastructure, a regulator has to ensure that the rolling stock is correctly configured, maintained, and may safely operate on the network. This requires a national or even multinational rolling stock asset register that can only work if there is a unique identification of the vehicles. And to be clear, this is complementary to the international registry registering security interests in rolling stock. Currently, most states have no common identification system for all types of rolling stock nationally, let alone internationally. This is a serious challenge for any government looking to set up a rolling stock register. If rolling stock cannot be identified, it cannot be regulated. The protocol provides a pain-free solution for regulators and governments. Using the URVIS numbering system and the UN Model Rules as the basis for the rolling stock register eliminates the need to set up and administer a national or international numbering system for rolling stock operating on a given network. This register then operates under local rules. The bonus for creditors and operators is that this marking of the rolling stock makes it ready to be financed with private capital, with the benefits of the protocol, as and when needed. Moreover, the global numbering system facilitates monitoring of rolling stock moving across different jurisdictions, or redeployed in another part of the world. It is available now, and crucially, its use is not dependent on a state having ratified the Luxembourg Protocol (although of course this is preferable). A market for private finance The railway world is turning. Future success in the rail sector will depend on public and private operators competing, with themselves and other modes of transport, on a level playing field with open access. And a close to €70bn/year market will need private finance at unprecedented levels. The availability and cost of such capital will be critical if the rail industry is to innovate, prosper, and become what it deserves to be for good social, economic and environmental reasons: the sunrise industry of the 21st century. The Luxembourg Protocol can only help to achieve this; we should embrace it. To quote South African Transport Minister Barbara Creecy, ‘the ratification of the protocol is an essential part of the rail open access strategy of government’. This article first appeared in the November 2026 issue of Railway Gazette International Read the issue

Now being adopted by a growing number of states, the Luxembourg Rail Protocol offers strong protections for private investors in rolling stock, leading to lower financing costs and other benefits, as Howard Rosen, Chairman of the Rail Working Group, explains.

Worldwide, it used to be said that rail was a sunset industry. No longer; the railway world is turning. Unless you are directly affected, you may not have noticed this yet, because institutional change in the rail sector happens so slowly.

But with some notable outliers, open access in both freight and passenger rail is either already in place or is coming. Governments and state-owned agencies are gradually withdrawing from the operation of both passenger and freight train services, or at least sharing, delegating, or concessioning operations to private operators.

An idea whose time has come

Early next year, 11 operators will be offering freight transport services on the South African rail network. Mozambique announced in June 2026 that it would follow the same strategy. ‘Our approach to logistics is clear: you cannot run logistics with a monopoly’, declared Minister of Transport & Logistics João Matlombe earlier this year. Other parts of Africa and the Americas are following, or looking to follow, the same path.

In Europe there is already a type of open access in rail freight, and this is developing in passenger rail with more open access in countries including France, Italy, Spain, Sweden, and the Czech Republic. This will have profound implications for the rail sector: in the future, if not already now, the primary focus of state budgets will be on railway infrastructure, leaving train operations to private companies or to publicly owned operators financed by the private sector.

However, this shift must also be accompanied by suitable changes to the way the rail sector is governed. To that end, the Luxembourg Rail Protocol to the Cape Town Convention is an international treaty that has now been in force for just over two years. The Rail Working Group is the not-for-profit association which supports the implementation of the treaty.

It has already been ratified by seven states (plus the EU in respect of its competences) and will play a critical role in this evolution in two key regards. One is obvious; the other may surprise you.

The protocol applies when a debtor asset lessee is based in a ratifying state. It is already making it easier and cheaper to finance rolling stock where there are no government guarantees. The treaty does this by creating a global legal framework that secures creditors, giving them clear rights on debtor default or insolvency, and providing a public international registry in Luxembourg, at which security interests may be registered. It applies to all types of rolling stock, from locomotives to wagons to metro trains and trams, new and used.

In praise of URVIS

The Luxembourg Protocol also introduces, for the first time, a global unique vehicle identification system (URVIS), whereby the international registry issues a 16-digit number on request. This is akin to the VIN number stamped on the chassis of every car, introduced more than 40 years ago. This number must be permanently attached to the vehicle in accordance with the UN Model Rules setting out minimum standards for the marking of railway rolling stock. At €15, the cost of an URVIS number is minimal. Tracking technology using the URVIS number allows creditors, keepers, insurers — and indeed operators — to track the location and use of the vehicles in real time.

This is a game changer. The key to being able to offer asset-based financing is the ability to unequivocally identify the collateral. If this is not possible, banks and other creditors will lend or lease based on the creditworthiness of the debtor/lessee, thereby locking out (or at least pricing out) smaller, entrepreneurial, but less well capitalised, operators.

Private operators need rolling stock. They can lease or buy it, often with bank credit. Effectively, this is the other side of the open access coin. The more private operators, the more the need for private capital. So the Luxembourg Protocol will be a key tool for private sector operators. Moreover, even state operators will be looking to utilise more private capital where government guarantees may be restricted for operations outside of the home jurisdiction, and are also increasingly being challenged by non-state actors pointing out the absence of a level playing field.

Why standards are essential

In many parts of the world, technical challenges remain, even beyond the existence of different gauges. Customisation of rolling stock and the lack of common standards continues to hinder the industry. The growing market for private finance of rolling stock will expose this as financially unsustainable. Standardised rail equipment operating across borders with harmonised technical standards will increase the residual values of rolling stock, thereby reducing lease rates and opening the way to secondary markets for rolling stock, cheaper maintenance, economies of scale for manufacturers, and lower prices for customers.

But this only works if there are common legal standards that provide security to creditors, enabling them to reduce risk and offer finance at competitive rates. That is why the Luxembourg Rail Protocol will play an increasingly important role in supporting operators seeking attractive finance rates; manufacturers looking to develop, against tough competition, domestic and export markets; and banks, export credit agencies and insurers striving to reduce risk and therefore their pricing.

In its recent report, Connecting Europe through High Speed Rail, the European Commission clearly acknowledged that private finance will be essential for the successful development of high speed rail in Europe, and it specifically invited member states to ratify the Luxembourg Protocol as a mechanism to help stimulate investment in rolling stock.

“

‘Currently, most states have no common identification system for all types of rolling stock nationally, let alone internationally’

” 

The hidden benefit

But there is another role that the Luxembourg Protocol will play, and this is less obvious. The availability, for the first time, of a global unique vehicle identification system for rolling stock is also highly relevant for regulators.
Where there are multiple operators running rolling stock on railway infrastructure, a regulator has to ensure that the rolling stock is correctly configured, maintained, and may safely operate on the network. This requires a national or even multinational rolling stock asset register that can only work if there is a unique identification of the vehicles. And to be clear, this is complementary to the international registry registering security interests in rolling stock.

Currently, most states have no common identification system for all types of rolling stock nationally, let alone internationally. This is a serious challenge for any government looking to set up a rolling stock register. If rolling stock cannot be identified, it cannot be regulated. The protocol provides a pain-free solution for regulators and governments.

Using the URVIS numbering system and the UN Model Rules as the basis for the rolling stock register eliminates the need to set up and administer a national or international numbering system for rolling stock operating on a given network. This register then operates under local rules. The bonus for creditors and operators is that this marking of the rolling stock makes it ready to be financed with private capital, with the benefits of the protocol, as and when needed. Moreover, the global numbering system facilitates monitoring of rolling stock moving across different jurisdictions, or redeployed in another part of the world. It is available now, and crucially, its use is not dependent on a state having ratified the Luxembourg Protocol (although of course this is preferable).

A market for private finance

The railway world is turning. Future success in the rail sector will depend on public and private operators competing, with themselves and other modes of transport, on a level playing field with open access. And a close to €70bn/year market will need private finance at unprecedented levels.

The availability and cost of such capital will be critical if the rail industry is to innovate, prosper, and become what it deserves to be for good social, economic and environmental reasons: the sunrise industry of the 21st century.
The Luxembourg Protocol can only help to achieve this; we should embrace it. To quote South African Transport Minister Barbara Creecy, ‘the ratification of the protocol is an essential part of the rail open access strategy of government’.

This article first appeared in the November 2026 issue of Railway Gazette International

Read the issue

Source: Railway Gazette

Advertisement